Coleman Pop Up Tent vs Traditional Tent: Which is Better?

Choosing between a Coleman pop up tent and a regular pole tent matters a lot for campers. This piece looks into the advantages and disadvantages of both. It aims to help you pick the best option for your camping adventure. We will cover topics like how fast they are to set up and pack, their sizes when packed, how long they last and their wind and rain abilities. We’ll also talk about how well they let air flow, how big they are, how easy they are to keep clean, and the costs.

Key Takeaways

• Pop-up tents set up and pack up 2-4 times faster than regular tents.¹
• Pop-up tents have a setup time ranging from 15 seconds to 2 minutes, while regular tents take 7-22 minutes to set up.¹
• Pop-up tents can be packed up in 1.75 to 3.5 minutes, while regular tents take 6-16 minutes.¹
• Pop-up tents have a larger packed size compared to traditional pole tents, making them less compact for storage and transport.
• Traditional pole tents generally offer better durability and wind protection than pop-up tents.

Introduction to Pop Up Tents and Traditional Tents

Pop-up tents and traditional pole tents are the primary kinds of camping shelters.² Pop-ups, like Gorilla Glow Tents, are loved for festivals. They are quick to set up. This means more fun outdoors, especially for solo campers or small groups. In contrast, setting up traditional pole tents takes longer because you must build the frame and attach everything.

Pop-up tents offer quick setup which is perfect for festivals. They are known for being easy to set up, providing more recreational time. However, traditional pole tents require more work. They need the frame to be erected and the tent to be layered with the roof covering.

² Gorilla Glow Tents, priced at £79.99, are great for two campers with a lot of gear.² Vango Sigma 300, a dome tent at £130, fits two people and their items well.² Regatta Vester 4, a tunnel tent at £310, balances space, weight, and height admirably.

² The Vis A Vis Coleman Spruce Falls 4, at £310, has two bedrooms facing a porch.² Bell tents, spacious but need care, are exemplified by the Boutique Camping Harlequin 5m Bell at £600.² It features quality canvas, vents, and windows. These elements are crucial for durability and comfort.

³ Dome tents are praised for being easy to pop up and strong once set.³ Cabin tents have straight walls and lots of space, making them perfect for families.³ For those on the move, backpacking tents are light and compact. These are ideal for hikers who need to travel light.

³ When buying a tent, look at how many it sleeps, its season range, weight, and how easy it is to put up. Also, check its weather resistance and how durable it is. These all affect its use and quality.

³ Well-known tents include the REI Co-op Half Dome 2 Plus and the Coleman Sundome.³ Keeping tents in good shape is key to making them last. Proper care means they can be used for a long time.

³ Three-season tents fit spring to fall, while four-seasons are for winter.³ Tents are not just for camping. They’re great for events like festivals or sleepovers too. Adding extras like footprints or loft storage can make them even better.

Coleman Pop Up Tent vs Traditional Tent

Definition of a Pop Up Tent

A pop-up tent is super easy to set up for camping. Just take off the strap and it pops into shape in about a minute.¹ These tents are great for people who want a fast way to camp, like families and those new to camping.

Pros and Cons of a Pop Up Tent

Pop-up tents are so quick you can do it in 15 seconds to 2 minutes.¹ Taking them down takes about 1.75 to 3.5 minutes. You don’t need to remove the poles when packing them away. They fit neatly in their bag too.¹ But, they might not handle strong winds as well as other tents.

Definition of a Regular Tent

Traditional tents need more time to set up than pop-up ones. You have to put the poles together and attach the tent and fly.¹ This process takes from 7 to 22 minutes. Packing up is similarly detailed and takes 6 to 16 minutes, depending on the size.¹

Pros and Cons of a Regular Tent

Regular tents are stronger against the wind. This is because they use better materials and often have stronger poles.⁴ They are more durable and can survive in rough weather. However, putting them away can sometimes be a hassle. You have to take care removing parts and fitting everything in the bag is not always easy.¹

Set Up Timing: Pop Up vs Regular Tent

Pop-up tents beat regular tents by a lot in fast set-up. They can be ready in 15-120 seconds. All you need to do is take off the strap and the poles pop up on their own.¹ Setting up everything properly with stakes and ropes might take another 1-2 minutes.¹

Pop Up Tent Set Up

Pop-up tents are super quick to set up. Some can be fully up in just 15 seconds. But, if you add stakes and ropes, the time is normally between 1.5 to 3.5 minutes.¹ This quick assembly is thanks to the built-in poles that instantly open up the tent.

Regular Tent Set Up

But regular tents are much slower. They take 2-4 times longer to set up than pop-ups.¹ Setting up a normal tent could take you between 7 to 22 minutes.¹ This is because you have to build the frame by adding poles and attach the tent fabric.

Choosing a pop-up tent means you can start enjoying your camping spot way faster. They are great for people who want to spend less time on set-up.⁴¹

Pack Up Timing: Pop Up vs Regular Tent

Pop-up tents beat out regular tents when it’s time to leave. Research shows you can typically fold up a pop-up tent in around 1.75 to 3.5 minutes. This method involves taking out the stakes, folding the tent, and smoothly putting it in its bag.¹ On the other hand, taking down a regular tent, like the Coleman Sundome series, usually takes longer. In fact, it may be 2-4 times more time-consuming than a pop-up of the same size.¹

Pop Up Tent Pack Up

Pop-up tents win in the speed department thanks to their simple, already-built design. Most can be back in their bag in just under 3.5 minutes, with the average time being 2 to 3 minutes.¹ This quick process is a huge help for campers ready to move on to their next spot.

Regular Tent Pack Up

Traditional pole tents, however, need more time to pack up. Tents like the Coleman Sundome can take 2-4 times longer to pack than their pop-up counterparts of the same size.¹ This is due to the disassembly of the pole frame and careful folding of the fabric, which increases the total time needed to put things away.

Packed Size Comparison

When looking at packed size, you can see a clear difference. Coleman pop up tents and traditional pole tents differ in size. Data shows pop-up tents are bigger when packed. This is because of their pre-assembled poles and frame. They fold into a larger package, usually over 3 feet long and 1 foot wide.¹ On the other hand, traditional pole tents pack into smaller cases. This makes them easier to carry and store when not needed.¹

Tent Model	Packed Size	Weight	Peak Height
Eurmax Standard 10×10 Canopy	–	64.3 lb	11.0 ft
Caravan Canopy V-Series	–	32.1 lb	9.2 ft
Clam Outdoors Quick-Set Escape	–	33.9 lb	7.5 ft
E-Z Up Pyramid	–	54.1 lb	10.4 ft
Eureka Tagalong Shelter	–	5.9 lb	6.3 ft
The North Face Wawona 6	–	20 lb 15 oz	76 in
Nemo Aurora Highrise 6P	–	18 lb 10 oz	77 in
Coleman Skydome 6P	–	19 lb 5.4 oz	72 in
REI Co-op Base Camp 6	–	20 lb 11.5 oz	74 in
Marmot Tungsten 4P	–	–	53 in

The table compares pop-up and traditional tents by their packed size, weight, and peak height. While we don’t have the exact packed size, the weight and peak height hint at it. Pop-up tents are usually bigger when packed. In contrast, traditional tents are more manageable in size.⁵⁶¹

Durability and Wind Protection

Traditional pole tents beat pop-up tents in durability and wind protection. They have a strong pole frame and tough fabrics. This helps them handle strong winds and tough weather better.¹ Pop-up tents are easy to set up but not so good with strong winds or heavy rain. Traditional tents, however, come with guy lines and extra stake points. These help make them more stable and wind-resistant, adding extra safety in tough conditions.

Studies show that¹ pop-up tents are not as durable or wind-resistant as regular tents. Regular tents provide better safety in bad weather.¹ This is very important for people camping in windy or mountain areas. They need a tent that can handle severe weather well.

Tent Type	Durability	Wind Protection
Pop-up Tent	Lower1	Lower1
Regular Tent	Higher1	Higher1

The table clearly shows that regular tents outperform pop-up tents in durability and wind protection. They are a better pick for campers who need dependable gear for tough outdoor conditions.

Ventilation and Breathability

Traditional tents might have better ventilation than pop-up tents, according to the facts.¹ They come with many mesh windows, vents, and adjustable rainflies. This lets campers tweak airflow to fit their needs and the weather, keeping the tent cool and dry.

Pop-up tents, on the other hand, have a fixed setup.¹ This often means less control over ventilation. Even though they do let air through, adjusting it finely like in traditional tents can be hard.¹For those needing precise ventilation control, especially in heat or heavy rain, this limitation might matter.

Choosing the right tent for good airflow depends on many things, like design and materials. It’s important to do your homework to find the best tent for staying comfortable and well-ventilated outdoors.

Available Tent Capacities

Comparing Coleman pop-up tents to traditional pole tents, there’s a big difference in sizes. Pop-up tents are mainly for 2-4 people, such as Coleman’s 2-Person and 4-Person Pop Up Tents.¹ On the other hand, pole tents come in larger sizes, like 6-person, 8-person, and 10-person models from Coleman. This shows pole tents have more options for big groups and families than pop-up tents do.¹

Tent Model	Price	Floor Area	Weight	Height	Number of Doors
MSR Habitude 6	$700	83 sq. ft. (120″ x 100″)	14 lbs.	77″	One
Kelty Discovery Basecamp 4	$120	53 sq. ft. (97″ x 79″)	8 lbs., 8 oz.	58″	One
REI Co-op Wonderland X	$1,249	70.5 sq. ft. (100″ x 100″)	35 lbs., 1 oz.	75″	Four
Mountain Hardwear Bridger 4	$780	62.5 sq. ft. (96″ x 90″)	18 lbs., 9.4 oz.	68″	Two
REI Co-op Base Camp 6	$549	84 sq. ft. (110″ x 110″)	20 lbs., 11.5 oz.	74″	Two
Mountain Hardwear Mineral King 3	$375	42.5 sq. ft. (90″ x 68″)	7 lbs., 1.2 oz.	48″	Two
The North Face Wawona 4	$400	58 sq. ft. (96″ x 90″)	13 lbs.	68″	Two

The data indicates that for small groups, pop-up tents are more suitable. Yet, if you’re camping with a bigger group or family, pole tents are the better choice. They offer more room and options, making them more versatile for different camping needs.⁷

Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance

Coleman pop-up tents and traditional pole tents differ in how easy they are to clean and maintain. It’s been proven that the design of traditional tents, with their complex structure, may be harder to keep clean. This is especially true when compared to pop-up tents, which have a simpler design.¹

Traditional tents need their poles and rainfly taken apart for cleaning. This process takes a long time. On the other hand, pop-up tents are much easier to clean. They can just be wiped down and packed away without all the dismantling.¹

But, both kinds of tents need the same kind of care. You should always dry and store them well to avoid mildew and damage. No matter what tent you have, following the maker’s cleaning and maintenance tips is key. This helps keep your tent in good shape for longer.⁸

Cost and Value Considerations

Looking at the Coleman pop up tents against camping tents, there are key differences in cost and value. Pop-up tents are usually cheaper, especially for small groups. A Coleman 2-Person Pop Up Tent costs about $50. The 4-Person tent is nearly $100.⁹

On the other hand, the traditional Coleman Sundome tents range from $70 to $180. This shows that for those on a tight budget, pop-up tents offer good value. They work well for individuals or small groups.⁴

For larger tents, pop-up models can cost more. The Gazelle T4 Hub Tent is $350.⁹ The value depends on the tent’s size and the buyer’s needs.

Pop-up tents are easy to set up quickly. But, traditional tents might last longer and be more versatile. These points are important when thinking about the tent’s overall worth.⁴ Choosing between a pop-up and a traditional tent is up to what’s most important to the camper and their budget.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Coleman pop-up tents and traditional pole tents have some main differences. These include how quick they are to set up and pack, their sizes when packed, how well they protect from the wind, how much air flows through them, how many people they fit, and their price.¹⁰ Pop-up tents shine in being super fast to set up and fold down easily. The Coleman canopy tent is fast to set up and costs $159.99¹⁰, offering 100 sq. ft. of shade.¹⁰ But, they might not hold up as well in strong winds and offer fewer ways to customize compared to pole tents.⁵ Pole tents, like the high-rated Eurmax Standard 10×10,⁵ need more time to set up but are sturdier, more flexible, and better for bigger groups. The Bravindew Waterproof Pop Up Tent can comfortably sleep 6.¹¹

The better choice between a pop-up or a pole tent depends on what the camper wants. This includes their camping needs, the weather they’ll face, and their budget.¹⁰ For instance, the E-Z UP Patriot ONE-UP Vented Technology Shelter can cost from $199 to $605 for special models,¹⁰ while the Caravan Canopy V-Series is more affordable at $106.⁵ Both types have their own good parts and can make camping fun and cozy.

Knowing the key differences lets campers decide what works best for their outdoor trips. Be it the fast setup of a pop-up or the sturdiness and flexibility of a pole tent, there’s a tent for every camping style and budget.

Recommended

• BEST BED TENT TO BLOCK OUT LIGHT FOR SLEEP
• BED TENT FOR TRAVEL: SLEEP COZY ON-THE-GO
• INDOOR BED TENT FOR CAMPING COMFORT & FUN